2016-11-24 AGM Transcript
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.
Rob Hunt [6:56 PM] Welcome to the 2016 Nottingham Hackspace AGM being held on Thursday 24th November at Antenna Rob Hunt [7:05 PM] Okay we're quorate at 103 members, 37 present, 8 represented by proxies and 58 proxied via email Rob Hunt [7:24 PM] AGM started at 19:24 [7:25] No AOB like every other AGM [7:25] Agenda: [7:25] Roll Call [7:25] State of the union [7:25] financial report [7:25] special resolution: definitions [7:25] special resolution: elections [7:25] Patrick McDonald [7:26] 1. State of the Union (hackspace) [7:26] up to 494 members [7:26] average of 8.9 members/month [7:26] Feel free to ask questions, Daniel will provide a mic [7:27] Tasos: question about members per month [7:27] Members per month is joined - left [7:27] Some team are struggling for members, especially #membership and #comms (edited) [7:28] Question about team membership: Can we sign up at any time if we didn't do it on the way in? [7:29] Yes [7:29] Kate: Comms team is currently only 2 people [7:29] James: We will be running some drives over the next year for teams [7:29] New Tools: mini lathe, milling machine, bench PSU, CNC mill, projectors, new fridge [7:30] Complaints: 14 since November last year, 1 still active [7:31] EMF: Electro Magnetic Field - big geek festival, we had a huge village there [7:31] Every 2 years, next one is 2018, keep an eye on the google group [7:31] We took 2 big things to EMF: Fire Pong by Mouse and Ian, also took Toby's Mystery machine [7:33] Hackspace 2.5, took on new space last December [7:33] Had loans from members in April this year [7:33] Also got a £10,000 lottery grant around the same time [7:34] Since December we've taken down many walls, cleared 4 skips and 2 lorries worth of rubbish [7:35] Hack evenings on Tuesdays making progress [7:35] Doors are taking much longer than expected [7:35] Budget was predicted at £1000 for 10 doors last December Ben Seeley [7:35 PM] joined #meetingminutes Rob Hunt [7:36 PM] Doors orders being finalised over the next few weeks [7:36] Progress should speed up once the doors are in place [7:36] We plan to move into the back of the downstairs around March/April next year [7:37] Question from Tasos: can we get an idea about what sort of things the complaints were about? (edited) [7:38] Things like misuse of tools, data protection issues, number of behaviour (safe spaces) complaints things like that [7:38] James F: I know the hackspace 2.5 has a lot of questions about progress, I'd just like to thank all the volunteers [7:39] Froggy: for those who weren't there the front floor in HS2.5 was raised, it was about 6-10 flat pack MDF boards with carpet glued to it and nailed [7:39] All the wood was damp and all the help to remove that was appreciated [7:39] James: Was everyone aware about the survey we sent out? [7:40] First question was to thing of a word to describe the hackspace [7:40] (word cloud on screens at Antenna) [7:41] Tried to classify them as negative/positive/neutral (edited) [7:41] 12 negative 12 neutral and 38 positive [7:41] We asked people if they volunteered at the hackspace [7:42] 35 said they did, 25 didn't [7:42] of people who did they spent 0-10 hours at the space [7:42] We had some questions on diversity - we wanted to figure out the make up of the space [7:43] to see if we could improve the situation in some way [7:43] vast majority is white, male, middle aged [7:44] we will release the full results at a later date [7:44] Quesiton: what was the percentage that was not white/male/middle aged [7:44] about half not middle aged (edited) [7:46] less than 10% is none-white or other [7:46] we have 494 members but only had around 70 responses so far so it's not fully representative [7:48] Matts going to move onto our financial report for the year [7:49] Turnover £62k, Expenditure £51k, Surplus £1725 (edited) [7:49] fixed assets £3822 [7:49] current assets, stock £52, debtors £6850 (rent deposit), £30k in bank (edited) [7:51] Richard: question about surplus [7:51] Toby: question - over the last year we've been looking at how much members pay per month, has this worked [7:51] Yes, positive improvement over the past 12 months [7:52] Additional £1500 fixed assets is from new fridge, 2 projectors and embroidery machine [7:52] Took in £41,761 in membership payments [7:53] Average of about £8.80 membership payments [7:53] Workshop income much higher this year: due to more workshops being run, EMF (sweets, barbot) [7:54] Snackspace £3,991 [7:54] Tool Usage £4323 [7:54] (all the laser cutter) [7:54] Tool Inductions £820 [7:54] Donations £452 [7:55] Members Box and RFID cards £63 [7:55] Material Shop £291 [7:55] Materials shop was missing a good portion of money so we're not sure we can continue it (edited) [7:56] Might have a solution to this in near future [7:56] Expenditure [7:56] £27k rent (due to new space downstairs) [7:56] £7k electricity [7:57] Other Utilities £1119 [7:57] Infrastructure £319 Joe [7:57 PM] joined #meetingminutes Rob Hunt [7:57 PM] Hackspace 2.5 £656 [8:00] Martin F: Heating solutions - electric heaters are expensive [8:00] We're considering electric panel heaters for HS2.5 and upstairs [8:00] Possibly have them on timers to prevent them being left on [8:01] A lot of the electricity is actually from the old light fittings upstairs [8:01] LED lighting is a significant outlay but long term savings [8:02] Other ways of heating the space is gas heaters but Bizspace have put restrictions on their usage now [8:02] Dominic: Questions about teams [8:02] some teams are meant to make money can you clarify which [8:02] Yes, snackspace and materials shop [8:04] Events expenditure is high because of several workshops where equipment was needed and EMF [8:04] End of the finances [8:05] Kate: thanks to everyone who has run a workshop this year, it has bought in money and more members [8:05] Next: Constitution [8:05] Going to quickly go over the 2 parts [8:05] First will be definitions [8:05] https://wiki.nottinghack.org.uk/wiki/2016-11-24_AGM_Agenda/Special_Resolution:_Definitions Rob Hunt [8:12 PM] Can 6.3.2 be change to a total of 4 or more [8:13] Can "normal decisions" be clarified for 6.3 [8:14] Josh: can you clarify what benefit the complex definition gives you [8:15] James H: the point is to help when there is a strong disagreement amongst the board, it leads to compromise and better decisions [8:15] Michael E: is it worth having this section 6 defined where it's used [8:16] Dominic: Just to confirm that this is something you already do but want to formalise it in the constitution [8:16] James H: Yes [8:17] Michael E: 6.1 use of dash make it looks like -N-1 [8:18] Change 6.3 to 6.3: with the definition [8:19] Moop: does the majority mean the majority of all current trustees? [8:19] Vote: [8:20] Clear Majority in favour [8:21] Next up will be Special resolution: Elections [8:21] https://wiki.nottinghack.org.uk/wiki/2016-11-24_AGM_Agenda/Special_Resolution:_Elections Rob Hunt [8:31 PM] We're looking at elections now - we've had quite a lot in the last 12-18 months and have rewritten some of the constitution based on what we've learnt [8:31] 1.7.1 covers stuff about standing down nick_b [8:32 PM] joined #meetingminutes Rob Hunt [8:33 PM] Michael: did trustees have to announce they didn't intent to re-stand in the past [8:33] No, but some did [8:33] Richard: standardise the capitals on Trustee Rob Hunt [8:39 PM] James F: 5.3.4 slight modification "ana election for all trustees should be run" [8:39] David C: in the vent that 1 steps down within the end and another steps down this is requiring an election to be run? [8:39] Yes (edited) [8:40] David C: would it make sense to defer to the upcoming man election? [8:40] 5.3.5 can accommodate this Mouse [8:41 PM] joined #meetingminutes Rob Hunt [8:42 PM] Josh: 5.3.5 why did you choose to have all the trustees rather than an EGM? [8:42] James H: it's not an easy thing to do or organise - 14 days notice is required [8:42] James H: may not be time to run one before the election needs to be run anyway [8:43] Michael E: 5.3.5 refers to deviations in 5.3 including itself [8:43] should be 5.4 to allow deviations from 5.3 [8:44] Moving onto 5.4 (will become 5.5) Rob Hunt [8:49 PM] 5.5.7 allows us to run elections with terms of different lengths [8:49] the winning candidate will be appointed the longer of the terms [8:50] Dominic: with 1 candidate what happens with a draw with the RON [8:50] next section deals with ties [8:51] Any more questions about these changes? [8:51] (none) [8:52] Abstain: 1 (via proxy in room) [8:52] Against: 0 [8:52] Vote passes [8:53] Constitution will be moving to Read The Docs type formatting we have used on the new rules [8:53] Pat McDonald [8:54] You should have seen an email regarding a temporary ban [8:54] Pats been a member for many years, been an ex member for the last year and rejoined a month ago [8:55] in the first 3 weeks of his membership we had 4 safe space complaints [8:55] in the past there has been 2 informal and 1 formal warning [8:55] Last Tuesday the trustees decided to enact section 4.4 of the constitution to remove a member [8:56] Given a letter informing him of 21 days to attend a meeting to decide on the ban [8:56] Pat tried to access the space and was given a copy of the letter [8:56] Russell was assaulted at the space and the police were involved [8:57] Pat wrote a letter with various complaints which various members may have received [8:58] Passed onto our legal representive who will deal with communications [8:58] Question: do you think he is a danger to the space? [8:58] James H: he has verbally abused members in the past [8:58] Question: are we/you in danger [8:59] James H: not likely unless he'd directed them at you [8:59] Kirsty: In his email he mentioned Women in Tech [8:59] Froggy: they have been emailed about the situation and have both responded [9:00] Dominic: I just want to say I have had great reason to be made uncomfortable by his actions in the past [9:01] Dominic: I don't think he is generally physically dangerous [9:01] James H: we need to decide what to do at the meeting in a few weeks regarding his membership Leah Hallissey [9:02 PM] joined #meetingminutes Rob Hunt [9:02 PM] James H: we don't think this will be a permeant ban but with a opportunity to be reviewed at some point [9:02] Matt L: is there any example of other hackspaces banning memebrs [9:03] Kate: Noisebridge has banned several members in the past Tony Shannon [9:03 PM] I believe Southampton did 4-5 years ago Rob Hunt [9:03 PM] London has also banned members for a period of time [9:03] Temporary ban is part of the complaints policy not the constitution [9:04] Toby: understand this is a difficult and new situation, thanks [9:05] Andrew: would this ban include open evenings? [9:05] Possibly if the decision is passed at the meeting [9:06] Tasos: can he collect belongings? [9:06] Yes, but he has to give 7 days notice and provide a list of items to allow us to sort it out [9:06] Question: I'm just wondering if you have anything in place to prevent incidents in the future? [9:07] Mouse has proposed new members inductions to possibly help but we don't think that would have worked in this situation [9:08] Andrew: If there is a way you can stop him sending more messages to us? [9:09] Richard: there is already a harassment warning which was centred upon when he tried to access the space but it's not related to his communications via email so please let trustees know [9:10] James H: I don't think he'll force himself into the hackspace - you don not have to let anyone into the hackspace [9:11] Matt Little: you shouldn't try and restrict someone if they are trying to force there way in, call the police and contact the trustees [9:11] James F: the email that several members got sent to - already people asking questions, wise not to have uncertainty on it [9:12] James H: we will be sending out an email to all members regarding this [9:13] Hazel: I introduced a new member to the space called Patrick Mcdonald [9:13] We'll make sure this is handled properly to avoid issues [9:15] (prize draw) [9:15] Thank you everyone for coming to support the space [9:15] --End of AGM--